Wednesday, March 26, 2008

American Idol

Here is my breakdown of tonight:
1. Ramiele - terrible
2. Chikezie - not good
3. Christy Cook - not great but the song will keep her around.
4. Michael Johns - if he could keep singing Queen songs, he could win, but that won't happen.
5. Carly (Tattoo girl) - OK, until the very last note, which was horrible.
6. David Archuleta - Michelle and I are convinced he sang an EFY song, not my favorite, but he will be fine.
7. David Cook - absolute stud - my new favorite. That guy is fantastic.
8. Syesha - she was absolutely great, she is now the best girl in my opinion.
9. Brooke White - booooooooooooorrrrrring. And annoying. But she will stay.
10. Jason Castro - I couldn't hate this guy more unless his name was Sanjaya. But, America is stupid and won't send him home yet.

Bottom 3:
1. Ramiele
2. Christy Cook or Carly Smithson
3. Chikezie
Leaving - probably Chikeze. Although, I wouldn't care if any of those 4 left at this point.

10 comments:

Shannon said...

I agree with everything and I wouldn't be surprised if that was an EFY song! :) Only Simon knew the artist. All in all I thought the whole show was on the boring side. Jason Castro needs to go next cause I can't stand to look at or listen to him again. But I guess there always needs to be one annoying one..Sanjaya, Chicken Little and now him.

Greg Garrick said...

David Cook has made it in to my top 3. Tonight's Billie Jean was brilliant. He should only remake 80's songs. Great!

Ramiele who is in my top 4 -- looked terrible and unfortunately sounded worse. She may be in the bottom 3 tomorrow.

Castro -- could you be less appealing? Boring performance, hard to watch and painful on my ears -- get a haircut!

Brooke -- nice start, keepin' it real for your peeps? I did enjoy her performance and she looked good tonight.

Chikeze -- did he perform tonight, I can't remember.

Syesha -- great voice and a personality to match

Michael Johns, for the first time was interesting mildly. He's a Lakers fan, so I can't dismiss him this week.

Kristy -- I liked it! I really did, way to hang in there.

Archuleta was Ok and Carly remains terrible. Please hide that disgusting tattoo!

Top 3 -- Cook, Brooke & Syesha

Bottom 3 -- Chikezie, Ramiele, Carly

Brady Fletcher Garrick said...

Why do you keep bring up the tattoos? Leave it alone!!! So annoying. Geez!!!

Chikeze - Great voice! I look forward to buying his albums.

Ramiele - Talentless. Please leave!

David - Amazing!!! Love that guy.

Bottom 3: Ramiele, Christie, Syesha (she is nothing special)

Shannon said...

I am so disappointed that Chikieze is gone. He didn't do well this week but the previous two he was awesome! Castro has no business still being in there

Carolyn said...

I think David Cook did awesome! He is now in my top 3. I do like Brooke White...She has a sexy voice, she's cute and she's L.D.S. It's cool watching her and knowing that she's endowed and manages to dress great AND modest. Good example....maybe the rest of the world can realize that it's actually possible to be modest and clean and people will actually still like you as an artist...imagine that!!! I think David A. is picking terrible songs and not showcasing his talent...I've seen youtube footage of him doing other songs and they were awesome.....get smarter David!!!
Syesha is the whole package...but unfortunately for her...there are already alot of famous singers that are too much like her.
Jason doesn't seem to bother me like he does all of you...but he's still going home soon...too many bad songs in a row.
Carly is good....
Michael's voice isn't nearly as memorable as David Cooks. He would do good as a lead in a band....and he's easy on the eyes! Seems like a nice guy....and a good song choice.
Ramiele...okay...she's good, but in all honesty I would be shocked if she won.
Kristy...I'm shocked she's still there after being in the bottom what? 4+ times in a row...is that a record??? She did look better and definately redeemed herself for the time being.
Top 4 David Cook
Brooke White
David A (w/ better song choices...plus he's got a huge fan base...and he's sweet)
Michael Johns

Amaya said...

AI has released the songs the contestants will sing next week. Here they are:

Ramiele: The Umpa Lumpa Song (could she get her pants up higher?)
Castro: More than Words by Extreme
Molly: "Sailing On" from Saturday's Warrior (What is that sound, rising up from the Earth? the sound of a clock ticking on"
Syesha: "I love your Smile" by Shanice or "ABC" by Jackson 5
Michael Johns: The Final Countdown and other arena classics
Kristy: The Star Spangled Banner
Archuleta: One Shining Moment
Scottish chick: "I got you babe" by Cher

Amaya said...

Wait a minute. Syesha hasn't sung "Midnight Train to Georgia" yet this season.

I would actually like to hear Molly sing "Toy Soldier" by Martika, and Archuleta sing "Soldier of Love" by Donnie Osmond or "Step by Step" by the NKOTB!

Amaya said...

David Castro: "Mmm-bop" by Hanson

Shannon said...

I actually WOULD like Archuleta to sing Soldier of Love! I think they should have a Broadway night and he could sing something from Joseph.
I like the idea of Castro singing Mmm bop! And why don't I know who Molly is?

Nikki said...

Molly (Mormon) = Brooke
I assume that's what Tim means. :)
Funny song choices Tim